Follow the daily refining market, check the physical buffer, then compare with PBF’s reported margin capture. Exact observations and benchmark substitutions stay visible.
StorageCurve analysis · ownership disclosure. The publisher owns PBF Energy shares and considers PBF a sector favourite. This tracker is our model of the margin environment; observed prices, proxy choices and assumptions are identified separately. Disclosure reviewed October 25, 2026. Explore Market Analysis →
PBF Margin Index · estimate44.14 $/input barrel2026-11-11 · gross spread before costs
Market proxy estimate · 0 of 5 exact regional benchmarks. Daily EIA prices are observed; location, grade and crude substitutions are listed below. Current matched price date 2026-11-11 · 5 calendar days old. Not PBF realized margin or an earnings forecast.
Regional weights: reported 2026Q3 throughput. LA/SF throughput is not separately reported; 50/50 is an assumption you can change. Current LA 50% / SF 50% of West Coast. History uses this fixed latest mix, not historical portfolio weights.
If the chart cannot load, use the recent daily observations below.
The index is a weighted gross price spread before costs, with all regional substitutions disclosed.
Proxy benchmark
East Coast
Dated Brent / NYH 2-1-1
+46.86 $/bbl
Index weight
31.80%
Index contribution
+14.90 $/bbl
Price substitutions and formula
EIA Europe Brent for the licensed Dated Brent assessment; NYH conventional regular for RBOB. NYH ULSD is observed.
Brent replaces ANS; EIA LA RBOB represents the gasoline leg without claiming identical CARBOB assessment; Gulf Coast jet replaces LA jet. LA CARB diesel is observed.
EIA observations used in the latest complete index date. Individual source latest dates can differ. USD/gallon product prices are multiplied by 42 only inside the crack calculation.
Observed price
Matched-day value
Unit
Latest source date
Series
WTI Cushing spot
89.62
USD/barrel
2026-11-11
PET.RWTC.D
Europe Brent spot FOB
92.14
USD/barrel
2026-11-11
PET.RBRTE.D
NY Harbor conventional regular gasoline
2.415
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPMRU_PF4_Y35NY_DPG.D
NY Harbor ULSD
4.204
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPD2DXL0_PF4_Y35NY_DPG.D
Gulf Coast conventional regular gasoline
2.538
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPMRU_PF4_RGC_DPG.D
Gulf Coast ULSD
4.106
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPD2DXL0_PF4_RGC_DPG.D
Gulf Coast kerosene-type jet fuel
4.035
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPJK_PF4_RGC_DPG.D
Los Angeles reformulated RBOB regular
2.913
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPMRR_PF4_Y05LA_DPG.D
Los Angeles ultra-low sulfur CARB diesel
4.349
USD/gallon
2026-11-11
PET.EER_EPD2DC_PF4_Y05LA_DPG.D
Recent daily index observations
Latest 12 provider dates · index in USD per crude-input barrel. Missing active legs remain unavailable.
Date
PBF index estimate
East
Mid
Gulf
LA
SF
2026-11-11
44.14
46.86
33.07
47.38
43.64
47.01
2026-11-10
45.61
48.84
32.79
49.36
45.34
48.45
2026-11-09
46.12
49.31
33.08
49.84
46.01
49.15
2026-11-06
46.49
49.80
36.36
50.01
44.75
48.04
2026-11-05
48.25
53.39
36.30
51.18
46.20
49.14
2026-11-04
50.91
55.54
35.18
52.45
53.07
54.37
2026-11-03
47.97
51.54
37.60
48.96
48.55
50.11
2026-11-02
43.99
46.46
34.12
44.94
45.72
46.68
2026-10-30
46.23
44.57
42.54
48.29
48.12
49.04
2026-10-29
47.65
45.12
42.36
50.41
50.50
52.09
2026-10-28
43.24
39.98
41.40
46.60
44.41
46.43
2026-10-27
38.73
34.53
42.67
42.13
37.68
39.84
Measured tracking error · pbf-benchmark-check-v1
How close are the regional proxies?
2024Q3–2026Q3 · 9 completed quarters. We compare the mean of available, same-day EIA crack observations with the same-quarter benchmark published by PBF. These are benchmark tracking errors, not errors against realised margins or EPS forecasts.
Use East Coast and LA as level context; treat Chicago and SF more cautiously. SF is retained as a diagnostic trend proxy, not a dependable SF margin level. Chicago has a large historical outlier. The headline basket retains all five exposures: deleting a weak region would silently change what it represents. These raw comparisons remain unadjusted. A separate experimental regional adjustment is tested below.
USD per crude-input barrel. MAE = mean absolute error; bias = proxy minus PBF benchmark. Direction compares consecutive quarter changes; the sample is small.
Proxy
Quarters
MAE
Bias
Worst absolute error
Direction matches
Our use
East Coast
9
1.51
+0.61
4.45
8/8
Retain: useful level proxy
Mid-Continent
9
3.73
+3.59
9.85
8/8
Direction context: large level outlier
Gulf Coast
9
2.63
-2.63
6.18
7/8
Retain with downward-bias caution
West Coast · LA
9
1.96
-1.63
7.85
8/8
Retain: useful level proxy
West Coast · SF
9
5.31
-5.31
10.46
7/8
Diagnostic only: weak level proxy
Default PBF proxy basket
9
1.00
-0.80
2.32
8/8
Market context: regional errors can offset
The basket’s low error partly reflects cancellation. Its MAE is 1.00 $/bbl, versus 2.78 $/bbl for the weighted absolute regional errors on those same dates. Positive Chicago errors can offset negative Gulf Coast and SF errors. That cancellation may not persist.
For changes between consecutive quarters, the basket’s mean absolute tracking error is 1.19 $/bbl, versus 7.21 $/bbl if the published benchmark basket were simply assumed unchanged. This is a descriptive flat-change reference, not a forecast competition.
What this says about the next quarter: East Coast and LA have been closer level proxies in this sample. Chicago and SF need a wider allowance for error. This small quarterly sample cannot establish a reliable future error band, and none of these figures validates an earnings forecast. Daily tracking errors can be larger than errors in quarterly means.
Quarter-by-quarter comparisons and original PBF sources
Every accepted region/quarter comparison. Basket rows compare a constructed blend of published benchmarks, not a company-reported consolidated benchmark.
No calibration, regression or future price estimate is used in this raw validation. Daily cracks are recomputed from the published quote fields. Each regional leg uses only dates with every required input available; the basket requires all active legs on the same day. Each observation has equal weight within a quarter. This may differ from the price vendor’s averaging calendar.
Accept a completed quarter only with at least 80% of its calendar weekdays observed and a matched observation within seven calendar days of each boundary. Holidays count in the coverage denominator. Insufficient quarters are excluded, not filled. 0 region/quarter comparisons excluded in this run.
The basket check always uses the 2026Q3 throughput mix with LA/SF split 50/50. The adjustable West Coast control above does not alter this fixed-reference diagnostic. We reweight both proxy and published benchmarks identically. This is retrospective tracking validation with latest-reviewed weights and comparative report columns, not a point-in-time investment backtest. The SF and LA benchmarks are separate published indicators, although realised West Coast results are combined.
MAE averages absolute quarterly deviations. Bias averages signed deviations. Worst error is the largest observed absolute deviation, not a future limit. Direction matches exclude nonconsecutive quarters and flat published-benchmark changes. A direction match says nothing about the size of a move.
StorageCurve model · experimental regional basis adjustment
Adjusted regional margin indicators
Locations stay fixed; their price differences do not. We correct persistent regional bias with a simple additive offset: raw proxy minus the median historical proxy error. A median limits the influence of a single extreme quarter. No fitted slope or extra market inputs are used. The offset combines grade, crude and location substitution effects; it is not an observed transport premium.
Regional adjustments help; the total basket did not improve. Gulf Coast, LA and SF get a separately labelled experimental adjustment. The three-region selection remains the one made on October 25: East Coast and Chicago stay raw. With Q3 added, the East Coast candidate now worsens both checks, while the Chicago candidate improves both; that small expanded sample has not prompted a change in the selected regions. The headline index, charts, regional contributions and reported company figures remain raw.
Current matched date 2026-11-11 · USD/input barrel. Current offsets use all reviewed, published quarters available on 2026-11-16. Adjusted figures are model estimates, not observed benchmark quotes or PBF realised margins.
Region
Raw proxy
Applied offset
Current indicator
Status
East Coast
46.86
0.00
46.86
Raw · no adjustment
Mid-Continent
33.07
0.00
33.07
Raw · no adjustment
Gulf Coast
47.38
+2.07
49.45
Experimental adjustment
West Coast · LA
43.64
+1.02
44.66
Experimental adjustment
West Coast · SF
47.01
+5.27
52.29
Experimental adjustment
Does the correction help on later quarters?
Fit each region’s candidate offset on its first four quarters, freeze it, then test on later quarters. The current offset above is subsequently refitted on all available reviewed quarters; the scores below do not test that refit. The second check uses only prior-quarter report columns published before each test quarter began, with at least two training quarters.
Mean absolute benchmark tracking error, USD/bbl. Candidate corrections are tested for all five regions, even where no correction is enabled. Lower is better; sample counts are shown for each check.
Region
Later quarters
Raw MAE
Candidate MAE
Publication-lag quarters
Raw MAE
Candidate MAE
East Coast
5
1.46
1.63
3
2.26
2.53
Mid-Continent
5
5.38
4.48
3
6.58
5.77
Gulf Coast
5
3.46
1.83
3
4.28
2.31
West Coast · LA
5
2.67
2.12
3
3.96
3.30
West Coast · SF
5
5.64
3.39
3
8.32
5.32
Why the headline stays raw: on the same 5 later quarters, its MAE is 1.08 $/bbl raw versus 1.12 $/bbl with the three regional corrections combined. Better regional estimates can remove helpful cancellation in the aggregate.
Test rows, training periods and limitations
The first split is chronological, not publication-date aware: some reviewed comparative report columns were published later. The publication-lag check handles those report dates, but uses today’s price histories, not original release vintages. Neither test is a point-in-time trading backtest. The fixed latest throughput mix and assumed 50/50 West split apply to the aggregate comparison.
These are exploratory tests with a small sample. Our decision to enable three regions was informed by these results; there is no untouched final test set. No confidence band or future accuracy guarantee follows. The basis can change with transport, outages, fuel specifications and local supply/demand. Reassess the selected regions when new quarterly reports are reviewed. A constant correction changes a level; it cannot repair missed changes in the regional price basis.
Publication-lag-aware candidate checks. All offsets in each row use only the listed previously published quarters.
Stocks: million barrels and exactly-five-prior-ISO-year seasonal mean. Domestic demand: product supplied, four consecutive weeks, YoY against the same ISO week in the preceding ISO year. Exports: four-week average, US only. PADD utilization describes all regional refiners, not PBF plant utilization. Regional demand and exports are not inferred.
National demand and export readings
National rates only. Four-week means in million b/d. Demand YoY uses matching ISO weeks; export YoY is not inferred.
Indicator
Week ending
4W mean
Demand YoY
Gasoline domestic product supplied · US
2026-11-06
8.729
-1.0%
Distillate domestic product supplied · US
2026-11-06
3.947
+4.2%
Jet domestic product supplied · US
2026-11-06
1.777
+1.8%
Gasoline exports · US
2026-11-06
0.913
—
Distillate exports · US
2026-11-06
1.310
—
Jet exports · US
2026-11-06
0.258
—
Products exports · US
2026-11-06
7.455
—
US and PADD inventory / utilization table
PADD 1, 2, 3 and 5 correspond to PBF reporting regions; these are regional market totals, not PBF facilities.
Indicator
Week ending
Level
Unit
5Y stock mean
Stock gap
Gasoline stocks · United States
2026-11-06
210.8
million barrels
209.5
+0.6%
Gasoline stocks · East Coast · PADD 1
2026-11-06
51.2
million barrels
51.3
-0.1%
Gasoline stocks · Midwest · PADD 2
2026-11-06
42.9
million barrels
43.8
-2.2%
Gasoline stocks · Gulf Coast · PADD 3
2026-11-06
82.1
million barrels
80.0
+2.7%
Gasoline stocks · West Coast · PADD 5
2026-11-06
27.4
million barrels
27.3
+0.4%
Distillate stocks · United States
2026-11-06
103.3
million barrels
112.6
-8.2%
Distillate stocks · East Coast · PADD 1
2026-11-06
23.8
million barrels
30.5
-22.0%
Distillate stocks · Midwest · PADD 2
2026-11-06
22.9
million barrels
25.2
-9.1%
Distillate stocks · Gulf Coast · PADD 3
2026-11-06
43.2
million barrels
42.0
+2.9%
Distillate stocks · West Coast · PADD 5
2026-11-06
10.2
million barrels
11.5
-11.1%
Jet stocks · United States
2026-11-06
42.0
million barrels
39.4
+6.5%
Jet stocks · East Coast · PADD 1
2026-11-06
10.4
million barrels
9.1
+13.6%
Jet stocks · Midwest · PADD 2
2026-11-06
6.8
million barrels
6.7
+0.7%
Jet stocks · Gulf Coast · PADD 3
2026-11-06
14.1
million barrels
12.9
+9.3%
Jet stocks · West Coast · PADD 5
2026-11-06
10.2
million barrels
9.8
+3.1%
Refinery utilization · United States
2026-11-06
95.2
percent
—
—
Refinery utilization · East Coast · PADD 1
2026-11-06
93.1
percent
—
—
Refinery utilization · Midwest · PADD 2
2026-11-06
96.9
percent
—
—
Refinery utilization · Gulf Coast · PADD 3
2026-11-06
95.4
percent
—
—
Refinery utilization · West Coast · PADD 5
2026-11-06
91.6
percent
—
—
Weekly block collected 2026-11-13T06:17:46+00:00. Product supplied and exports are US-only; no regional allocation. Gasoline stocks include blending components; distillate includes heating oil. Exports of gasoline include blending components from June 2023, so the definition has a historical break.
Company disclosures · quarterly
Realized margin versus the published benchmark
Report ledger through 2026Q3, reviewed 2026-11-03. New filings require source review and import; this is separate from automatic price updates.
Reported gross refining margin excludes special items and is before operating expense. Benchmark values come from PBF reports, not the daily EIA proxies.
USD per throughput barrel, except throughput in barrels/day. Capture gap = reported gross refining margin excluding specials − same-quarter benchmark. Regional RIN expense is not disclosed in these releases.
2026Q3 · reported regional data. West Coast is not split into separate realized LA and SF results.
Region
GRM ex specials $/bbl
GAAP gross margin $/bbl
Opex $/bbl
Throughput b/d
East Coast
33.54
25.93
5.93
293,800
Mid-Continent
36.86
29.18
6.40
156,400
Gulf Coast
27.61
19.11
7.16
180,500
West Coast · combined
38.64
25.55
10.41
293,100
Compliance and crude slate context
EPA RIN prices and reported crude discounts
D4 · 2026 vintage2.135 USD/RIN
Transfer week 2026-09-21
D6 · 2026 vintage2.074 USD/RIN
Transfer week 2026-09-21
EPA observations through 2026-09-21 · source app updated 2026-10-15T11:00:35.499Z · collected 2026-11-13T04:21:56+00:00. Weekly transaction observations are published with a lag; they are not current dealer quotes or PBF costs.
EPA weekly separated-RIN transaction prices, weighted by traded RIN volume across QAP types within each transfer week, RIN vintage and D-code. Reuses EPA SUM(Price_INTERMEDIATE_PRICE)/SUM(Price_TOTAL_RINS). Different vintages are never spliced. Weekly transfer-date label is retained; publication may be monthly. Not a live quote or PBF expense.
Recent EPA RIN transaction prices
Latest 12 D4/D6 observations for the selected RIN vintage. A missing D-code/week stays unavailable.
Transfer week
RIN vintage
D-code
USD/RIN
2026-09-21
2026
D6
2.0744
2026-09-21
2026
D4
2.1348
2026-09-14
2026
D6
1.9934
2026-09-14
2026
D4
2.2030
2026-09-07
2026
D6
2.1392
2026-09-07
2026
D4
2.1447
2026-08-31
2026
D6
2.0630
2026-08-31
2026
D4
2.0949
2026-08-24
2026
D6
2.1971
2026-08-24
2026
D4
2.1601
2026-08-17
2026
D6
2.1223
2026-08-17
2026
D4
2.0674
Quarterly market indicators published by PBF · USD/barrel. These are reported historical averages, not daily live differentials. Effective RIN basket is a market indicator, not regional company expense.
Unavailable as live exact inputs: Chicago CBOB and ULSD; San Francisco CARBOB, CARB diesel and jet; Los Angeles jet; LLS spot; ANS spot; WCS spot; Maya spot; Licensed Dated Brent assessment; NYH RBOB spot. Quarterly reported differentials are not carried forward into daily crude prices.
Q4 2026: $8.0 per share, with forecast regional spreads
The central forecast gives about $0.98 billion of underlying, fully-converted earnings. The weaker and stronger cases give $3.0 and $12.7 per share. The central forecast now predicts regional spreads for the rest of Q4. The weaker and stronger cases stress that forecast and company assumptions; they are not company guidance, consensus or a probability interval.
Observed prices and forecast remainder. Prices cover 2026-10-01–2026-11-11: 30 common observation days out of 66 calendar weekdays, or 45%. The other 36 weekday slots use forecast spreads, including elapsed dates with no complete quote set. The latest ten complete observations, 2026-10-29–2026-11-11, are the starting level; season, recent change and the trailing-year level determine the forecast adjustment. The latest successful calculation is dated 2026-11-13, generated 2026-11-13T06:17:46+00:00. The earlier frozen snapshots remain available.
Automatic updates use the existing daily PBF collector at 07:15 Europe/Stockholm and other successful PBF refreshes. New prices replace forecast dates, and the spread features are recalculated. Company assumptions, the original spread coefficients and their November 3 validation stay fixed. New company guidance and a new quarter require review.
Last successful estimate retained. The latest refresh did not pass validation, is overdue, or the reviewed update window has ended. Check the estimate date and price coverage above. Status checked 2026-11-13T06:17:46+00:00.
The Q3 miss came mainly from company margin capture, especially Toledo. Q4 now starts with Q3 realised regional margins and operating costs, management’s Q4 throughput ranges, and the latest diluted share count. The earnings model maps each region’s own EIA proxy directly to its reported gross refining margin. It no longer applies a capture ratio measured against a different published benchmark to that proxy. This removes one source of basis mismatch; it does not establish that Q3 capture will persist.
Q4 conditional estimates. USD millions except EPS, throughput and tax. Each scenario changes both the unobserved market remainder and company assumptions; all retain the same observed prices.
Q4 estimate
Weaker remainder
Central forecast
Stronger remainder
Throughput, barrels/day
925,000
955,000
985,000
Gross refining margin before Opex
1,522
2,170
2,855
Refining operating expense
750
673
664
Underlying operating profit
522
1,319
2,051
Underlying fully-converted net income
369
978
1,553
Underlying EPS, USD/share
3.0
8.0
12.7
Forecasting the rest of Q4
The spread forecast starts with the latest ten-day regional mean. It then estimates the change to the rest-of-quarter average using the change between the latest and preceding ten observations, distance to the trailing 252-observation mean, and the median same-quarter seasonal change from the previous three years. One pooled model is used across all regions, with damped coefficients to limit unstable fits. The coefficients stay fixed at the November 3 review while current feature values and the prior-year seasonal remainder move with the latest price cutoff. The central forecast is therefore allowed to rise or fall instead of holding today’s spread fixed.
The frozen November 3 validation used a rolling-origin check at day 27 of each quarter. In that check, the model’s mean absolute remainder-spread error was 3.53 $/bbl, versus 3.88 for the last-ten-day mean. There are 13 test quarters (52 correlated region/quarter rows), Q3 2023–Q3 2026. Each fit uses only earlier completed quarters. The overall gain is mainly West Coast; Mid-Continent slightly worsens. All histories are revised data, and the method was selected after inspecting these checks. The automatic forecast later moves beyond that original 27-day cutoff; these frozen scores do not validate every later horizon. This is preliminary evidence, not untouched validation or an EPS accuracy guarantee.
EIA’s October 6 outlook also expects easing distillate crack spreads as inventories recover slightly. That is qualitative context, not an exact regional price input. The tracker’s inventories and utilisation help assess whether the forecast’s environment is changing; the fitted price forecast uses the three disclosed price features. It does not contain an invented inventory-to-price uplift or a licensed futures curve.
What carries forward from Q3
For each region, Q3 reported GRM divided by its same-date Q3 proxy mean gives a model conversion ratio. Multiply that ratio by the scenario’s full-Q4 proxy to estimate Q4 GRM. West Coast uses the same assumed 50/50 LA/SF proxy blend in both quarters. These are proxy-to-company ratios, not PBF’s published benchmark capture percentages. There is no extra $1.97 EPS uplift to compensate for the Q3 miss.
USD per input/throughput barrel. 63 common Q3 price dates. Central Q4 proxy combines observed dates with the assumed remainder; it is not an observed quarterly average.
Region
Q3 proxy
Q3 reported GRM
Model ratio
Q4 observed proxy
Recent ten-day spread
Forecast remainder spread
Central Q4 proxy
Central GRM
Opex
East Coast
64.02
33.54
52.4%
45.48
49.14
48.44
47.09
24.67
5.93
Mid-Continent / Toledo
63.82
36.86
57.8%
47.27
36.34
36.17
41.22
23.81
6.40
Gulf Coast
66.08
27.61
41.8%
47.32
49.28
48.24
47.82
19.98
7.16
West Coast, combined
63.24
38.64
61.1%
45.64
48.30
46.28
45.99
28.10
10.41
At central volume, a $1/bbl change in realised GRM changes after-tax model EPS by about $0.54. A $10/bbl change in all four regional proxy spreads over the unobserved remainder changes EPS by about $1.58, holding conversion ratios fixed. A $25m change in SBR equity income changes it by about $0.15.
Volume, costs, debt, tax and share assumptions
PBF’s October 29 release guides Q4 throughput to 925,000–985,000 b/d: East 300,000–320,000; Toledo 155,000–165,000; Gulf 180,000–190,000; West 290,000–310,000. The model uses low / midpoint / high, each over 92 days. Martinez and Paulsboro turnarounds finished in October; the central volume already follows the new guidance and receives no separate restart bonus.
Weaker/central/stronger cases set unobserved proxy spreads to 80% / 100% / 120% of each regional remainder forecast. They also add −$3 / $0 / +$3 to East and Gulf GRM, −$6 / $0 / +$6 to Toledo, and −$5 / $0 / +$5 to West, in dollars per barrel. These are explicit stress choices, not fitted error bands. Weak Opex adds $1/bbl outside West and $1.50 there; strong Opex subtracts $0.25 and $0.50 respectively.
Model assumptions, not Q4 company guidance. USD millions except shares and tax.
The central operating bridge carries forward Q3 after separating PBF’s $62.4m share of SBR equity income; SBR production guidance is not enough to forecast its profit. The regional-to-consolidated reconciliation preserves the difference between rounded regional per-barrel estimates and company dollar totals, rather than hiding it in corporate costs. Its Q4 persistence is also an assumption.
PBF reported Q3 net interest of $27.2m and repayment after quarter-end of $800m of 9.875% notes. A full quarter of gross coupon savings would be $19.75m, but repayment timing and lost interest income on cash matter. The central $17m net interest is an assumption, bracketed by $25m and $8m. We use 25% central tax and Q3’s 122.756464m diluted fully-converted shares, rather than Q2’s 26% and 121.066763m. Tax and dilution can still change. No tax credit is assumed on a loss.
What the historical check can and cannot establish
Applying the previous quarter’s direct proxy-to-GRM ratio to the next quarter’s prices gives a regional GRM mean absolute error of 5.89 $/bbl across 12 region/quarter pairs in Q1–Q3 2026. Simply holding the previous realised margin unchanged gives 9.01 $/bbl on those same pairs. The largest regime change is Martinez’s restart, which the ratio cannot predict.
The prior report must have been published before the target report. This is a completed-quarter price diagnostic using today’s revised histories, not a quarter-start price forecast. The method was inspected after seeing the outcomes; there is no untouched holdout, validated EPS error band or proof that it improves the original model. Two-quarter smoothing also failed to reliably handle the recent changes. The change here improves consistency and transparency, while leaving capture uncertainty visible.
Inspect every direct-ratio GRM check. USD/bbl; positive error means the model was too high.
Before quarter completion, full-quarter proxy = (observed proxy sum + unobserved weekday slots × forecast remainder proxy) / 66. Once the provider has moved into the next quarter and at least 80% of Q4 weekdays have common quotes, the completed-quarter mean uses observed dates only. Weekday slots include holidays and dates with missing quotes, so the weighting is a model convention, not the vendor’s eventual averaging calendar. Observed quotes are never filled. Regional GRM × throughput × 92 days gives gross margin; deduct Opex and D&A, add the disclosed reconciliations and SBR once, then deduct interest, add other income, apply tax and divide by fully-converted shares. Special items, insurance settlements and share-price effects are not forecast. Download latest inputs and estimate history · Frozen November 3 spread forecast · Original $7.7 carry-forward snapshot · Methodology.
Saved Q4 estimate history (14 versions)
Latest 30 saved versions; the JSON download contains the full quarter index. Each source link preserves that version’s complete inputs. Identical repeat runs do not add versions.
The frozen central estimate was $10.81, compared with PBF’s adjusted fully-converted EPS excluding special items of $12.78. The shortfall was $1.97, or 15.4% of reported adjusted EPS. The original October 26 snapshot is retained below.
The largest error was carrying Q2 margin capture into Q3. Toledo’s reported GRM reached $36.86/bbl against our $28.90 estimate; its capture of the published benchmark rose from the assumed 45.1% to 67.5%. East Coast capture also improved. West Coast’s capture ratio was close, but our benchmark proxy was too low. The Chicago proxy was too high, partly concealing the Toledo company-margin miss. Total throughput was slightly below our estimate, so higher total volume was not the explanation.
Sequential EPS reconciliation. Each row replaces another forecast input with the reported outcome, retaining earlier replacements. The order allocates interaction effects; these are accounting contributions, not independently identified economic causes.
Replacement
EPS change
Running EPS
Frozen central estimate
—
10.81
Published benchmarks instead of price proxies
+0.26
11.06
Actual regional capture instead of Q2 carry-forward
+1.38
12.44
Actual throughput and regional mix
-0.11
12.33
Actual regional operating costs
+0.16
12.49
Regional-to-consolidated dollar reconciliation
-0.07
12.42
Actual depreciation
-0.03
12.39
Actual corporate, logistics and equity bridge
+0.27
12.66
Actual net interest and pension income
+0.09
12.75
Actual adjusted fully-converted tax reconciliation
+0.21
12.96
Actual diluted share count
-0.18
12.78
Reported EPS rounding
+0.002
12.78
Q3 regional GRM and published-benchmark capture. West uses the assumed 50/50 published LA/SF blend. These capture ratios differ from the direct proxy-to-GRM ratios used in Q4.
Region
Estimated GRM $/bbl
Reported GRM $/bbl
Assumed capture
Reported capture
Estimated proxy $/bbl
Published benchmark $/bbl
East Coast
30.63
33.54
47.8%
51.8%
64.02
64.77
Mid-Continent / Toledo
28.90
36.86
45.1%
67.5%
64.06
54.64
Gulf Coast
28.08
27.61
41.2%
40.0%
68.12
69.06
West Coast, combined
35.73
38.64
54.1%
53.4%
66.08
72.39
The reconciliation ends at reported adjusted net income of $1,568.6m divided by 122.756464m diluted fully-converted shares, before EPS rounding. The tax row reconciles the fully-converted adjusted presentation, including conversion and special-item tax effects; it is not just the GAAP tax rate. GAAP EPS was $12.54. Rebuilding the outcome for this review does not make the original forecast an exact reproduction of PBF’s non-GAAP accounting, and it does not turn one quarter’s error into a reusable EPS correction. PBF Q3 release and reconciliations.
StorageCurve earnings model · frozen October 26, 2026
Q3 2026: frozen central estimate $10.8 per share
Q3 results published October 29, 2026. PBF reported adjusted fully-converted EPS excluding special items of $12.78 and GAAP diluted EPS of $12.54. The frozen central estimate was $10.81; reported adjusted EPS minus that estimate is +1.97 per share. The model’s underlying EPS and PBF’s adjusted EPS are not identical accounting measures. Read PBF’s Q3 release. The original scenarios and inputs below remain unchanged.
The frozen central case points to about $1.31 billion of underlying, fully-converted earnings, or $10.8 a share. The cautious and strong cases run from $6.5 to $13.3. These are our model scenarios, not company guidance, analyst consensus or a statistical confidence interval.
At the October 26 cutoff, the quarter’s prices were available but PBF’s results had not yet been published. The central case carries forward Q2’s regional margin capture and operating costs, with Q3 throughput at the midpoint of management’s published range. West Coast matters: Q2 followed the Martinez restart, while the Q3 plan included a late-quarter hydrocracker turnaround.
Archived pre-results nowcast, frozen October 26. Price observations cover July–September only. Company results used for calibration stop at Q2 2026. Q3 results were scheduled for October 29. This October 26 estimate is stored separately from the daily tracker and will not silently refit to the Q3 result. No actual Q3 result enters the frozen model; the published outcome is shown separately above when available.
Model estimates, USD millions except EPS and throughput. Underlying EPS assumes full conversion and excludes unmodelled special items; it is not a GAAP EPS forecast or an exact reproduction of PBF’s non-GAAP presentation.
Q3 estimate
Cautious
Central
Strong
Throughput, barrels/day
900,000
930,000
960,000
Gross refining margin before Opex
2,098
2,685
3,061
Refining operating expense
747
674
665
Underlying operating profit
1,113
1,808
2,214
Underlying fully-converted net income
791
1,308
1,612
Underlying EPS, USD/share
6.5
10.8
13.3
The assumptions that move the result
Capture means reported gross refining margin excluding special items divided by the matching published benchmark. The central case uses Q2’s ratio for each region. That is a carry-forward assumption, not a proven relationship. The downside cuts capture by eight percentage points, or twelve for West Coast; the strong case adds five points. Volume uses management’s low, midpoint and high guidance respectively. The price inputs stay fixed across all three cases.
Central regional bridge. Capture and operating cost anchors come from the Q2 release; Q3 benchmark proxies and modelled margins are estimates. West Coast uses an assumed 50/50 LA/SF benchmark blend.
Region
Q3 benchmark proxy $/bbl
Assumed capture
Model GRM $/bbl
Opex $/bbl
Throughput b/d
East Coast
64.02
47.8%
30.63
5.61
310,000
Mid-Continent
64.06
45.1%
28.90
7.27
160,000
Gulf Coast
68.12
41.2%
28.08
6.59
180,000
West Coast
66.08
54.1%
35.73
11.58
280,000
Across the central case’s 85.56 million barrels, a $1/bbl change in realised GRM moves model EPS by about $0.52 after tax. A five-percentage-point change in capture across all regions moves it by about $1.71. That is why benchmark tracking accuracy alone cannot establish earnings accuracy.
Scenario costs and the full earnings bridge
Quarter volume = daily throughput × 92 days. Regional GRM = adjusted benchmark proxy × assumed capture. Sum GRM less regional Opex, subtract D&A, add the residual operating bridge, subtract net interest, apply tax, then divide by assumed fully-converted shares. A loss receives no assumed tax credit.
The residual operating bridge is $-37.1 million in the central case. It reconciles rounded Q2 regional GRM and costs, plus Q2 D&A, to reported adjusted operating income. It includes corporate, logistics, equity and reconciliation effects; it is not a separately reported expense line. We do not add logistics profit or SBR earnings again.
All values below are Q3 model assumptions, USD millions except tax and shares. The Q2 financial table supplies historical anchors, not Q3 guidance for these lines.
Assumption / bridge
Cautious
Central
Strong
Residual operating bridge
-62.1
-37.1
-22.1
Depreciation and amortisation
175.0
165.0
160.0
Net interest expense
45.0
40.0
35.0
Underlying pre-tax income
1,068.4
1,767.9
2,178.8
Model tax
277.8
459.7
566.5
Assumed fully-converted shares, million
121.1
121.1
121.1
All cases assume 26% tax and 121.066763 million shares, carrying forward Q2’s share count rather than predicting Q3 dilution. Relative to Q2, cautious Opex rises $1/bbl outside West Coast and $1.50 there; strong Opex falls $0.30 and $0.50 respectively. The residual operating bridge shifts by −$25m / $0m / +$15m. D&A is $175m / $165m / $160m and interest $45m / $40m / $35m. September’s exchangeable-note financing is known; its precise interest and diluted-share effects are not separately modelled.
Frozen inputs, regional corrections and what could be wrong
Each regional quarter average uses matched daily observations, with at least 53 of Q3’s 66 calendar weekdays and observations near both quarter boundaries. Gulf Coast, LA and SF use the separately tested median-bias corrections frozen for this forecast; East and Chicago stay raw. These corrections are estimates of missing benchmark basis, not additional profit or a RIN adjustment. The forecast uses regional guidance volumes, not the daily index’s Q2 throughput weights. Its 50/50 West split is fixed and independent of the adjustable daily-tracker control.
Frozen Q3 input means, USD/crude-input barrel.
Proxy leg
Days
Raw mean
Offset
Adjusted mean
East Coast
63
64.02
0.00
64.02
Mid-Continent
64
64.06
0.00
64.06
Gulf Coast
63
66.08
+2.04
68.12
West Coast · LA
63
63.60
+0.96
64.57
West Coast · SF
63
62.87
+4.73
67.60
The largest risks are changed margin capture, refinery availability, crude slate, product yields, hedging and compliance costs. The underlying capture assumption may already reflect RIN effects; we do not subtract an EPA RIN basket again. Insurance proceeds, inventory-accounting adjustments, debt-extinguishment charges and other special items can make reported GAAP EPS materially different. This model has no validated historical EPS error band. It does not forecast cash flow, working capital or a share price.
Download the frozen inputs and assumptions. The snapshot includes Q3 daily quotes, pre-Q3 company anchors, calibration training rows and source links. Later data refreshes do not overwrite it.
Market payload collected 2026-11-13T06:17:46+00:00. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration API v2; EPA EMTS public RIN dashboard; PBF Energy earnings releases. Retrieval timestamps do not replace observation or release dates.
Sum of five proxy cracks × reported regional throughput weights. West Coast is split 50/50 between LA and SF as an explicit adjustable assumption, not reported plant throughput. Historical daily curves are reweighted to this fixed latest reviewed mix; this is not a point-in-time earnings backtest. Missing any active price leg makes the index unavailable; weights are never renormalized around missing prices. All five regional benchmarks are proxies, even though individual EIA prices are observed.
Generic cracks use gasoline:diesel ratios 1:1, 3:1 or 2:1, divided by 2, 4 or 3 input barrels. PBF regional proxies use the separate jet blends listed on their cards. Positive does not mean net profitability. All component units, series identifiers, observations, weights, reported results and source links are available in the normalized data.
Market spreads are the starting point for company margins.
A crack is a product-price basket less crude cost per input barrel. PBF’s own product ratios are retained, while missing locations and grades are explicitly substituted with observed EIA prices.
Reported quarterly capture and operating expenses provide company context. This tracker does not turn a spot spread directly into net income.
Index construction, regional proxies, physical confirmation and company reporting.
What does the PBF Margin Index estimate?
It is a throughput-weighted basket of five regional gross crack proxies in USD per crude-input barrel. It describes the market price environment for PBF, before refinery operating costs. It is neither PBF realized margin nor an earnings or share-price forecast.
Which PBF regional weights are used?
East Coast, Mid-Continent, Gulf Coast and combined West Coast throughput come from the latest reviewed PBF quarterly release. Their sum is the denominator. The weight quarter, publication date, source link and each contribution are shown.
Why is there an adjustable LA share?
The reviewed earnings tables report Torrance and Martinez together as West Coast. They do not disclose separate LA and SF realized margins or throughput. The default splits West Coast equally as a visible modelling assumption; the control changes only that split.
Does the historical index avoid look-ahead bias?
No point-in-time backtest is claimed. The entire historical price curve is recomputed at the latest reviewed throughput mix. This constant-mix view isolates market moves; it does not reconstruct PBF historical portfolio weights.
What happens if one PBF proxy leg has a missing quote?
All quotes in a regional crack must share the identical EIA observation date. A missing active leg makes the composite unavailable. No interpolation, forward fill or automatic weight redistribution is used. A zero-weight leg does not constrain the index.
Which daily PBF benchmarks are exact?
None of the five daily regional curves is claimed to reproduce PBF licensed benchmarks exactly. The underlying EIA prices are observed, but grade, location or crude substitutions make the derived regional curves proxies. Each card states every substitution. A separate experimental regional view adds tested median-bias corrections for Gulf Coast, LA and SF; the headline basket stays raw because combining those corrections did not improve its test error. The Tracking accuracy section compares quarterly means with PBF published benchmarks; SF is a weak level proxy and Chicago has a large outlier in the reviewed sample.
How are the PBF regional product proportions handled?
The PBF January 2026 benchmark appendix includes half diesel and half jet in the Mid-Continent and LA distillate barrel, and one quarter diesel plus three quarters jet in SF. These proportions are retained, with unavailable prices replaced only by explicitly named observed proxies.
How are standard 2-1-1, 4-3-1 and 3-2-1 cracks normalized?
Convert gasoline and diesel from USD/gallon to USD/barrel using 42. Weight their proceeds by 1:1, 3:1 or 2:1 respectively, divide by 2, 4 or 3 crude-input barrels, then subtract the chosen crude price. Standard cracks do not contain the jet blend used in some PBF benchmarks.
Why is New York gasoline marked as a PBF proxy?
The free EIA NY Harbor series is conventional regular gasoline, whereas PBF benchmark documentation names RBOB. The tracker shows the EIA grade honestly and does not relabel it as a RBOB futures contract or the missing spot assessment.
How are Chicago, LLS, ANS and San Francisco gaps treated?
Chicago gasoline and diesel use Gulf Coast product prices as proxies. LLS and ANS use Europe Brent as a proxy. SF product legs use LA gasoline, LA CARB diesel and Gulf Coast jet. No missing exact assessment receives a fabricated price.
Which PADD areas matter for the PBF tracker?
The weekly panel covers US totals plus PADD 1, 2, 3 and 5, corresponding to the four reported PBF refining regions. PADD totals describe all reporting market participants and cannot identify PBF plant inventories, operating rates or outages.
How does the PBF panel define seasonal inventory gaps?
Gasoline, distillate and kerosene-type jet stocks are compared with the same ISO week and weekday in the preceding five ISO years. Five observations are required. Gasoline stocks include blending components and distillate includes heating oil.
How is demand growth measured in the PBF panel?
National product supplied is averaged across exactly four consecutive weeks and compared with a four-week mean ending in the matching ISO week of the prior ISO year. It is an implied domestic consumption proxy and can be revised. Missing weeks invalidate the comparison.
Are regional PBF demand and exports estimated from national totals?
No. Weekly product supplied and exports are displayed for the US. Stocks and refinery utilization have separate PADD series. The tracker does not allocate national demand or exports to PBF or to regions without a matching series.
How often do PBF market inputs refresh?
A focused daily collector refreshes EIA daily spot observations and checks the weekly physical and EPA blocks. Recently retrieved weekly blocks can be reused for up to 18 hours. Provider data may lag collection; observation, source-update and retrieval dates are kept separate.
Which PBF realized margin is compared with the benchmark?
The quarterly table uses reported gross refining margin excluding special items, per barrel of throughput, a non-GAAP measure. GAAP gross margin is stored separately. Refinery operating expense is shown separately and is not already deducted from the reported gross refining margin.
How is the PBF capture gap calculated?
For East, Mid-Continent and Gulf, subtract the published same-quarter PBF benchmark from reported same-region gross refining margin excluding special items. For West, the LA/SF benchmark blend is explicitly assumed using the selected LA share. The difference is descriptive and includes costs, yields, grade and location effects; it is not pure operating efficiency.
Are D4 and D6 prices the same as PBF RIN expense?
No. EPA prices are volume-weighted separated-RIN transaction prices by transfer week, RIN vintage and D-code. The EPA ratio of price-times-volume sums to volume sums aggregates QAP types correctly. PBF regional RIN expense is not disclosed in the reviewed earnings releases and stays unavailable.
Are crude discounts available in the PBF tracker?
The reviewed quarterly PBF market tables publish WTI minus WCS, Dated Brent minus Maya, WTI minus LLS and WTI minus ANS. These are dated quarterly indicators, not current daily quotes. Missing live LLS, ANS, WCS and Maya prices remain listed as coverage gaps.
Can I subtract the PBF RIN basket again to estimate earnings?
The effective RIN basket is a reported market indicator, not a clean standalone regional PBF expense. Actual margin capture can already reflect compliance effects. Subtracting it again can double count. Earnings also require throughput, outages, operating expenses, logistics, corporate costs, depreciation, financing, taxes and share count. New quarterly filings require review before entering the report ledger. The early Q4 2026 scenario separates observed prices from assumptions for the unobserved remainder, with Q3 regional company data, Q4 volume guidance and explicit financing, SBR, tax and share inputs. It is a dated scenario rather than a completed-quarter forecast. The archived Q3 2026 estimate and its error review remain visible, with its original inputs unchanged. It adds explicit capture, volume, cost, financing, tax and share assumptions; it is not the daily index and is not a GAAP EPS forecast.